2026 Season Review

Published on 18 November 2026 at 14:28

There's absolutely no way around it. The 2026 season was my worst season since legalization way back in 2018. That it was also the worst season for several other successful MLB handicappers does not make it feel any better, but it may stop me from making unncessary adjustments that could only compound on the problem. 

Baseball is super high variance. Okay, this happened. I'll even look at a lockout that potentially costs us 2027 games as a positive, as it leaves more time to prepare for the next season. With advancements in AI coming so quickly, almost anything you can think up may be possible...as long as you get to it before Skynet ends us. 

But let's start with the positive before we cover the elephant in the room and there were two good things that happened this season. 

The Postseason

MLB postseasons have been good to me for quite a while and while, similar to the 2026 regular season, this was not my best postseason, but it was a positive one that helped bring the nose up slightly. 

This may not be completely accurate because of a few minor tracking errors on my part and some prediction market makes that were never taken, but the gist of it is there. As is probably appparent, the most success was in the Divisional Round in the first week of the month of Ocbober. 

Strikeout Props

Sometime around the end of May, I complely overhauled my strikeout projection method to incorperate park and weather effects more consistently. It was, without a doubt, the best decision I made all season. 

Ever since the Wakler Buehler NLCS game at Citi Field in 2024, where I first learned about headwind/tailwind pitch effects, I've been looking for a way to accurately capture those effects. Park effects were already there (Statcast), but thanks to Kevin Roth's Weather Edge, I find a way to add in weather effects on strikeouts too. Sometimes the sample sizes aren't ideal, but we work with what he have. 

Apparently, Microsoft's AI, Copilot, recently found God and now refuses to analyze anything it considers gambling related (which includes sportsbetting, fantasy and poker, among other things), but before it did, it made this nifty litlte chart for my strikeout props after the overhaul. 

Surprisingly, most of my success was with overs, pariticularly due to those park and weather effects. Two parks stood out. Everyone knows that Seattle is the most pitcher friendly park in the league, though the market still failed to price up visiting pitchers high enough on occasion. I don't think nearly as many people realized how much American Family Field in Milwaukee boosts strikeouts. 

We can just look to their own pitchers' Home/Road strikeout rates or even look at what happened to pitchers like Corbin Burnes or Freddy Peralta after leaving. 

A lot of my success this season was playing pitchers to exceed their strikeout props in Milwaukee. 

Use my code when signing up on Novig: A5BD9F

https://share.novig.us/verification?referralCode=a5bd9f

2026 Season Recap

Now for the bad news. There's no way of getting around it. 

The season started rough, but after an uptick in mid-April and handing around even in May, instead of taking off, a massive crater was dug starting in June and the bleeding didn't stop until the last week of the season. 

I couldn't explain it. I lost games I should have lost about as often as I should have. I lost coin flips much more often than I would have expected and I struggled winning games I should have won. 

I regularly check pitching performances on Statcast, along with player cards posted on Twitter by PitchersList and others. Following @mlb_simulator, it was exceptionally frustrating seeing so erratic results. 

The process still felt right, considering what I was examining underneath the hood in many of these games. 

There certainly were bad decisions over the course of a season, but overall, I wasn't doing much differently than I have in either of the last few profitable years. If anything, I was tightening things up. 

It's not all variance, but I've played enough poker to know that you can and will run worse than you ever thought possible over a longer period than you ever thought you could when there's a large enough sample.

Of course it was unpleasant that this came during my first year writing for Action Network, but that's also why I like to dole out a lot of information in my write ups. To me, that's always more valuable than how I interpret it. Others may come to a completely different and better conclustion based on the same information or things that they fight that I may have missed. 

There is so much available information and so many games that its impossible to cover everything for a 15 game slate in just a few hours or even a full day. 

Up Next

Hopefully the 2027 season, but even if not, I think I can find plenty of ways to stay busier than I'd like to be most days. 

I'm working on a few baseball ideas over the off-season, one which some people already know about, which already appears on this site. It already functions as a useful tool, but I don't want to push it too voraciously, until it's a finished product. 

Others are in the same vain. Some are just fun projects. 

I've seen what people playing OOTP are doing with AI and it just looks like a lot of fun. Maybe I'll dedicate a page or two to soem of my leagues if the visuals appear interesting enough. 

Again, I'm sorry this is so overdue (if anyone actually cares) and don't want anyone to think I was hiding from or brushing off the results, it's just that once baseball season ends, everything you put off for 7+ months now needs to be done. 

Add comment

Comments

There are no comments yet.